How should we compare implementation effort and timeline for MANTL vs nCino?

Instead of relying on generic estimates, ask each vendor and partner to outline realistic milestones, internal roles, risks, and cutover strategies. Map those to your Salesforce footprint, internal skills, and change-management maturity. MANTL may deliver a focused, faster deployment for deposits, while a broad nCino program can take longer but transform more journeys.

How do we calculate ROI when comparing MANTL and nCino?

Start with a before-and-after baseline for approval rate, funded rate, time-to-decision, abandonment, and products per relationship. Estimate uplift by key journeys and connect it to net interest income and fee revenue. Then compare that upside to one-time and ongoing costs—licenses, implementation, and internal resources—to model payback periods and long-term ROI for each platform.

How can The Pedowitz Group help us decide between MANTL and nCino?

The Pedowitz Group starts with strategy, customer journeys, and revenue impact, then helps banks evaluate MANTL, nCino, and adjacent tools through that lens. Services include vendor-neutral assessments, business-case development, implementation planning, and post-go-live optimization focused on funded accounts, loan volume, and lifetime value.

How does MANTL stack against nCino for digital banking?

In short, MANTL is typically the better fit when your top priority is modern, high-conversion digital account opening for consumers and businesses, while nCino is stronger when you need a broad, Salesforce-based operating layer for commercial, small business, and complex lending. Many banks use them together: MANTL for the front door and nCino for onboarding, workflow, and servicing. Your best choice depends on which gaps matter most over the next 12–24 months—funded accounts, time-to-decision, origination efficiency, or full credit lifecycle.

What Really Changes When You Pick MANTL vs nCino?

Primary “Job to Be Done” — MANTL focuses on digital account opening and deposits growth with optimized UX. nCino focuses on credit, workflows, and the broader banking operating model, especially for commercial and small business lending.

Front-End Experience vs. Back-Office Depth — MANTL usually delivers a more streamlined, consumer-grade onboarding journey out-of-the-box. nCino shines in structured workflows, approvals, and documentation across lines of business.

Configuration & Change Management — nCino’s Salesforce foundation gives you a powerful platform but often requires admin skills, governance, and change control. MANTL emphasizes a purpose-built, opinionated experience with fewer decisions to make for deposits journeys.

Core & Fintech Integrations — Both support core and KYC integrations, but your core provider, card processor, and fraud stack can tilt the decision. Map which vendor already has proven adapters for your environment.

Analytics & Revenue Measurement — Winning with either platform requires clean attribution: connecting digital journeys to approvals, funded accounts, utilization, and lifetime value. That’s where a revenue marketing framework is critical.

Total Cost & Operating Model — License and implementation are only part of the investment. Factor in internal skills, governance, adoption, and continuous optimization when comparing options and building the business case.

How to Compare MANTL and nCino for Your Bank

Use this evaluation sequence to move beyond demos and feature lists and into measurable impact on funded accounts, loan volume, and cost-to-serve.

Clarify → Map Journeys → Score Fit → Design Stack → Pilot → Scale → Govern

Clarify strategic goals: Decide if your next 12–24 months are primarily about deposit growth, account opening, and CX (favoring MANTL), credit lifecycle and commercial lending (favoring nCino), or a hybrid front-door + LOS model.
Map signature journeys: Document end-to-end flows for consumer checking, small business accounts, and priority lending products. Highlight pain points like drop-off, re-keying, and manual underwriting.
Score vendor fit by journey: For each journey, rate MANTL and nCino on UX, configuration, integration pattern, and compliance controls. Identify where each is “best in stack” instead of searching for a single hammer.
Design a realistic stack: Decide whether MANTL is your digital front door integrated into nCino, or whether nCino’s own digital layer is “good enough” given budget and timeline.
Plan a measurable pilot: Choose 1–2 use cases—such as consumer checking or small business account opening—and define baseline KPIs (approval rate, funded rate, time-to-decision, abandonment).
Launch and optimize: Instrument funnels, run A/B tests on offers and flows, and iterate routing rules and underwriting thresholds with a cross-functional growth squad.
Govern and re-invest: Stand up a recurring digital banking revenue council to review performance, resolve cross-team issues, and reallocate budget to the highest-ROI journeys.

MANTL vs nCino Evaluation Matrix

Capability	MANTL Best-Fit	nCino Best-Fit	Owner	Primary KPI
Digital Account Opening UX	Optimized consumer and small business account opening with strong front-end experience.	Sufficient when paired with Salesforce experience cloud and strong internal UX resources.	Digital Banking	Application Start Rate, Abandonment Rate
Commercial & Small Business Lending	Can participate at the front door but not a full commercial LOS.	Structured workflows, covenants, documentation, and approvals for complex credit.	Credit / Commercial Banking	Cycle Time, Approval Rate, Exposure Quality
Platform & Ecosystem	Purpose-built layer with curated integrations for account opening and KYC.	Salesforce-based “banking OS” with broader platform and partner ecosystem.	Technology / Architecture	Change Velocity, Integration Effort
Configuration & Governance	Faster opinionated configuration for deposits journeys and campaigns.	High configurability, but requires Salesforce skills and governance.	Digital / PMO / IT	Time-to-Change, Defect Rate
Data, Analytics & Revenue Reporting	Rich funnel analytics for account opening; requires downstream stitching for LTV.	LOS-centric data for approvals, balances, and portfolio performance.	Analytics / RevOps	Funded Accounts, Portfolio Growth, ROMI
Marketing & Journey Orchestration	Strong when paired with a modern MAP/CRM to trigger journeys off account-opening events.	Strong for lifecycle and servicing triggers tied to credit milestones.	Marketing / CX	Funded Rate, Activation, Cross-Sell Lift

Client Snapshot: Choosing a Digital Banking Stack That Actually Grows Funded Accounts

Banks that win with platforms like MANTL and nCino treat them as part of a revenue system, not just a tech project. One regional institution started by redesigning its digital front door and revenue marketing model, then layered technology to support that blueprint. The result: higher funded-account growth, faster approvals, and clearer attribution to marketing and sales plays. See how a banking client made the shift: Banking Case Study.

However you land on MANTL, nCino, or a combination, you still need a governed revenue engine to connect digital journeys to balances and fee income. That’s where a financial-services-specific revenue marketing model and clear journey maps make the difference.

Frequently Asked Questions About MANTL vs nCino

Is MANTL or nCino better for community and regional banks?

It depends on your growth levers. If you need to modernize digital account opening and deposits quickly, MANTL often creates more visible impact at the front of the funnel. If your biggest pain is complex lending workflows, credit approvals, and Salesforce consolidation, nCino may be a better first move. Many institutions ultimately use both in a layered stack.

Can MANTL and nCino work together in one architecture?

Yes. A common pattern is to use MANTL as the customer-facing digital front door for deposits and select products, with nCino handling back-office workflow, credit decisioning, and onboarding. The key is designing integration points, data ownership, and shared KPIs upfront so the stack behaves like one system to the customer and frontline teams.

How should we compare implementation effort and timeline?

Go beyond generic “months” estimates. For each platform, ask vendors and partners to outline realistic milestones, internal roles required, key risks, and cutover strategy. Then map those to your bank’s capacity, Salesforce footprint, and change-management maturity. A smaller, focused MANTL deployment may be faster for deposits, while a broad nCino program can take longer but touch more journeys.

Which platform is stronger for commercial and small business lending?

nCino is generally stronger for commercial, CRE, and small business lending, especially if you want to standardize credit policies, covenants, and documentation. MANTL can still add value at the top of the funnel, capturing high-intent leads and applications that then flow into a LOS like nCino or your existing platform.

How do we calculate ROI for MANTL vs nCino?

Start with a before-and-after baseline: approval rate, funded rate, time-to-decision, abandonment, and products per relationship. Then estimate uplift by journey (e.g., consumer checking, business accounts, key lending products) and connect to net interest income and fee revenue. Finally, layer in one-time and ongoing costs—licenses, implementation, internal resources—to compare payback periods and long-term ROI.

How can The Pedowitz Group help with the decision?

We start with strategy, journeys, and revenue impact, then help you evaluate platforms like MANTL, nCino, and adjacent tools through that lens. That includes vendor-neutral assessments, business-case development, implementation planning, and post-go-live optimization focused on funded accounts, loan volume, and lifetime value—not just go-live dates.

Pick the Right Digital Banking Stack for Growth

We’ll help you compare MANTL and nCino against your goals, map the journeys that matter most, and build a roadmap that grows funded accounts and loan volume with clear attribution.

Get your growth audit Learn About FI-AI Agent

Explore More

How Banks Increase Funded Accounts Banking & Financial Services Growth Customer Journey Map (The Loop™)

How Does MANTL Stack Up Against nCino for Digital Banking?

What Really Changes When You Pick MANTL vs nCino?

How to Compare MANTL and nCino for Your Bank

Clarify → Map Journeys → Score Fit → Design Stack → Pilot → Scale → Govern

MANTL vs nCino Evaluation Matrix

Client Snapshot: Choosing a Digital Banking Stack That Actually Grows Funded Accounts

Frequently Asked Questions About MANTL vs nCino

Pick the Right Digital Banking Stack for Growth

Get in touch with a revenue marketing expert.

Send Us an Email

Schedule a Call

Solutions

Resources

About TPG